What is the Role of a Custody Evaluator in North Carolina?

Understanding the Role of a Custody Evaluator in North Carolina

In the midst of divorce or separation, determining the future of a child's living arrangements can be both emotionally charged and complex. North Carolina, like many states, utilizes the expertise of custody evaluators to assist the court in making informed decisions about child custody. A custody evaluator is a neutral third-party professional—often a psychologist, social worker, or similarly qualified individual—tasked with assessing the family situation and making recommendations regarding the best interests of the child.

The Custody Evaluation Process

The process begins when a judge orders an evaluation, usually at the request of one or both parents' attorneys. The evaluator conducts thorough investigations which include home visits, interviews with parents, children, and sometimes other relevant parties such as teachers or relatives. They also review documents related to the child's well-being such as school records and medical histories.

Throughout history, the role of these professionals has evolved. Originally, custody decisions were heavily influenced by the 'tender years doctrine,' which assumed that young children should be with their mothers. However, modern evaluators focus on a variety of factors to determine what will best serve the child's interests, without presumptions based on age or gender.

Factors Considered by Custody Evaluators

When making their assessment, evaluators consider several factors:

After completing their investigation, custody evaluators prepare a detailed report for the court including their recommendations for legal and physical custody.

Custody Evaluation Recommendations

The evaluator's recommendations can range from sole custody to one parent to various forms of joint custody. These recommendations are not binding on the court; however, they carry significant weight given the evaluator's expertise and thorough investigation.

For instance, in a notable North Carolina case, Craig v. Craig, the evaluator's findings played a critical role in reversing an initial custody decision after uncovering concerns about one parent's mental health and its potential impact on the child.

Choosing a Custody Evaluator

Selecting an experienced and qualified evaluator is crucial as their report can greatly influence the outcome of a custody case. Parties should look for professionals with specific training in child development and family law. In North Carolina, evaluators are often selected from a court-approved list.

Contesting Custody Evaluation Findings

If one party disagrees with the findings, they have the right to contest them in court. This typically involves presenting evidence that challenges the evaluator's conclusions or questioning their methodology.


The role of a custody evaluator in North Carolina is vital in ensuring that decisions about a child’s future are made with careful consideration of all pertinent factors. While emotionally difficult for families undergoing separation, these evaluations aim to prioritize children's well-being above all else.