← New York

What is New York's law on the exposure of children to domestic violence?

Understanding New York's Stance on Child Exposure to Domestic Violence

New York State takes the exposure of children to domestic violence very seriously. Recognizing the profound impact that witnessing such acts can have on the psychological and emotional well-being of minors, New York law treats exposure to domestic violence as a factor in determining child custody and visitation rights.

Under New York law, domestic violence is defined broadly to include not just physical harm, but also the threat of harm, and can encompass emotional and psychological abuse. When it comes to children, any act that allows a child to witness domestic violence—or be present during an incident—can have legal consequences.

When determining custody and visitation rights, family courts in New York consider the 'best interests of the child,' a standard that includes evaluating any history of domestic violence within the family. The courts may deem a parent unfit for custody or unsuitable for unsupervised visitation if they have exposed their child to such harmful environments. In severe cases where a child's safety is at risk, a court may order supervised visitation or restrict parental rights entirely.

Moreover, exposing children to domestic violence can also lead to charges under child endangerment statutes. Under Penal Law § 260.10, a person is guilty of endangering the welfare of a child when they knowingly act in a manner likely to be injurious to the physical, mental, or moral welfare of a child less than seventeen years old. This can include instances where a child is allowed to witness domestic abuse.

In some historical cases, such as Nicholson v. Scoppetta, New York courts have grappled with the complex issues surrounding children who are exposed to domestic violence. The Nicholson case highlighted the challenges in balancing the protection of children with the rights of parents who are themselves victims of abuse, and not perpetrators.

Family intervention programs and protective services in New York often engage with families where domestic violence is present to ensure the safety and well-being of children. These services work towards providing safe environments for children, either by removing them from dangerous situations or by offering resources and support to help rehabilitate families.

In conclusion, New York's approach to addressing the exposure of children to domestic violence is multifaceted, focusing on protecting the welfare and best interests of children while navigating the complexities of family dynamics affected by abuse.