New York's laws on child support modification due to financial hardship.

Understanding Child Support Modification in New York

When a parent faces financial hardship, it can impact their ability to meet child support obligations. In New York, the law recognizes that circumstances change, and there is a legal framework in place to address modifications to child support orders. This article explores the nuances of child support modification due to financial hardship in the state of New York.

Grounds for Child Support Modification

New York's family law allows for the modification of a child support order if there has been a substantial change in circumstances. Financial hardship can certainly qualify as such a change. The loss of a job, significant reduction in income, or a serious medical condition that affects earning capacity might all be grounds for seeking a modification.

A parent seeking modification must file a petition with the family court that issued the original child support order. The court will then evaluate the claim of financial hardship by considering factors such as the current income and expenses of both parents and the needs of the child.

Legal Criteria for Modification

The standard for modification of child support in New York is based on three primary criteria:

If any of these criteria are met, the court may consider modifying the child support order.

Documenting Financial Hardship

The burden is on the petitioner to prove financial hardship. This requires a detailed accounting of finances, including income statements, tax returns, and proof of any factors contributing to reduced earning capacity. A parent who voluntarily reduces their income or becomes underemployed without good cause may not be eligible for a reduction in child support.

Judicial Discretion and Considerations

Judges have discretion when reviewing petitions for modification and will weigh several factors:

It's important to note that any modification will only affect future payments and cannot retroactively change past due amounts.

Case Example: Matter of Scott v. Goins

A historical reference that illustrates this process is the case Matter of Scott v. Goins. In this case, the court found that the non-custodial parent had experienced a substantial change in circumstances due to loss of employment. Consequently, the court ordered a temporary reduction in child support payments until the parent could secure new employment.


Financial hardship can be an unpredictable hurdle that affects a parent's ability to pay child support. In New York, while there is an avenue for those genuinely experiencing significant changes in their financial situation to seek modification, it comes with strict criteria and rigorous proof requirements. It is advisable for parents facing such hardships to consult with an attorney who can guide them through this complex legal process.